It is beyond disturbing and disappointing that when a migrant is charged with a crime in the U.S., conservative media outlets jump on the news and try to portray the crime as part of a broader trend that migrants are engaged in an ongoing crime wave.
So I was glad to see the New York Times and John Oliver recently puncture holes in the myth of “migrant crime.”
“It’s no accident that Republicans were focusing so hard on immigration,” John Oliver, Host of “Last Week Tonight,” said in reference to this month’s Republican National Convention in Milwaukee.
“Recent polling shows it’s the second most important issue among Americans. But a big reason for that is the relentless, bad-faith fearmongering around the issue by the Republican party themselves, perhaps best summed up by the startling growth this year of the toxic phrase ‘migrant crime,’” said Oliver.
The Guardian noted Oliver’s comments in a recent article. “There is no migrant crime wave happening right now. In fact, there is no crime wave at all. Crime in general has been trending downward in recent years, including this one,” Oliver said.
U.S. rates of crime and immigration “have moved in opposite directions in recent years. After illegal immigration plummeted in 2020, the murder rate rose. And after illegal immigration spiked in 2021 and 2022, murders plateaued and then fell,” notes German Lopez, a reporter for the New York Times in a July 18 article.
Lopez points out that undocumented migrants “have an incentive to avoid trouble with the law so they do not get caught by the authorities and deported.”
“Despite claims from conservative media and campaign rhetoric pointing to immigration as the cause of crime increases, there is no evidence that immigration — and in particular the recent influx of immigrants to Democratic-run cities — is causing a ‘crime wave,'” the Brennan Center for Justice noted in late May.